| Platinum | Bernie's Diner |
| Gold | Sophies Kitchen |
| Silver | Montana Jack's |
| Bronze | Proof Donuts |
| Top Pick | Hog Wild Cafe |
| Top Pick | Red Rooster Cafe |
| Top Pick | Stella's Kitchen and Bakery |
| Top Pick | The Local |
| Top Pick | The Sassy Biscuit Co. - Billings |
| Top Pick | Tippy Cow Cafe |