| Platinum | Bullman's Pizza of Billings |
| Gold | Village Inn Pizza Parlor |
| Silver | Pie Guys Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Carbone's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | American Classic Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Jet's Pizza |
| Top Pick | MacKenzie River Pizza Co. |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom |
| Top Pick | Redneck Pizza & Chicken |
| Top Pick | Your Pie Pizza |